Freed on FIA consistencyIMS story

Aston Martin Vice TP Freed slams FIA stewards over ‘very inconsistent’ rulings

Freed accepted his own penalty in Mexico. He says the FIA should have applied the same standard in Brazil, where he also disputed the racing that decided the D3 win.

Wadz513 min read
Fernando Alonso’s Aston Martin throws up spray during sprint qualifying at Shanghai in 2024.
S8 · R6China

“In my honest opinion they are very inconsistent with their ruling,” Freed said in an interview ahead of Shanghai. The Aston Martin vice team principal pointed to two incidents at Interlagos that he says went unpunished. One, in his view, looked much like the contact that earned him a penalty a week earlier in Mexico. He laid down the gauntlet by saying "If they can't fix this then it shapes a negative upon our league."

Freed went in too hot at Turn 12 on lap 11 and gave us the low-tech version of push-to-pass. Aban was still alongside when the Aston took the whole exit and pushed him off. The FIA gave Freed five seconds and a penalty point. The standard penalty for this offence. Freed remembers the wheels hooking and says he knew he was at fault.

Mexico, lap 11 — Aban and Freed

Aban on the left, Freed on the right. Both onboards through Turn 12, then a half-speed replay.

1 / 1
Split-screen replayMexico, lap 11 — Aban and Freed
YouTube ↗

Freed described the other driver in his Brazil comparison only as “a certain driver”. He acknowledged that incidents can differ, then asked the FIA to stick to the standards it had already set. “I’d hope to see more consistency especially when they’ve set precedent by ruling on very similar incidents in the past,” he said.

The stewards took no action over the contact with Trident

On lap 30, By!q reported being pushed wide as Trident passed him. By the apex, the VCARB was no longer significantly alongside on the outside. That left Trident free to take the racing line on exit without leaving By!q a car’s width. The stewards found Trident had given him room while they were alongside and pulled clear before moving across, so they took no further action. IMS Rule 3.3.6

Brazil, lap 30 — By!q and Trident

By!q on the left and Trident on the right. The half-speed replay pauses at the apex to show why By!q was no longer owed room on exit.

1 / 1
Split-screen replayBrazil, lap 30 — By!q and Trident
YouTube ↗

Asked separately about the finish in Brazil, Freed said bad luck and “trident failing to race fairly” had cost him the win. He reported contact on the climb towards the main straight before the last lap. In his account, Trident closed the space between the two cars and their wheels hooked. Trident told the stewards he had left room on the inside and argued that Freed moved towards him as the straight kinked to the right. The stewards found both drivers had room up the hill and neither had clearly squeezed the other before their wheels caught. That made it No Further Action (NFA) under Rule 3.6.2, which generally leaves contact on a straight unpenalised unless one driver is completely at fault. The last two laps at Interlagos

Brazil, lap 35 — Freed and Trident

Freed’s chase camera and Trident’s onboard, followed by both onboards at half speed.

1 / 1
Split-screen replayBrazil, lap 35 — Freed and Trident
YouTube ↗

Fair stewarding or a coordinated campaign to rob Aston Martin of much-needed points? You’ve seen the replays. You decide.

Trident kept his first IMS win. Freed took second back from By!q (jjoh5152 in-game) and crossed the line 0.480 seconds behind the Williams. Freed and Trident head to Shanghai on 69 points each. If both start the reverse sprint, Freed will line up immediately ahead of Trident again. Final Brazil standings · Shanghai sprint format

Brazil — Trident takes the lead

The Williams draws alongside Freed on the climb to the main straight as By!q closes in.

1 / 1
Broadcast · Laps 35–36Brazil — Trident takes the lead
YouTube ↗
Brazil — Freed retakes second

Freed gets back alongside By!q in the infield and the broadcast follows the three cars to the flag.

1 / 1
Broadcast · Lap 36Brazil — Freed retakes second
YouTube ↗
Official IMS broadcast coverage

Watch the race

D3 · Season 8 Round 6

Reader feedback

Was this story worth your time?

Your response helps the news team make the next story better.

Loading feedback…
Keep exploring

Explore this story